Thursday, May 20, 2010

Huulk verses....( extracted from a conversation on Hulk v Spider-Man

yes the short answer is Hulk. But as you are doing a report on the topic, I figured you'd rather have opinions that support the thesis.
I would say that your best "answer" will have to be multi-layered, answering the noted expectations of various scenarios, or the less intelligent simple discourse, chiseled down to a simplistic "blow for blow"
Also is a win to the death of either combatant? This falls outside marvels commercial reasoning, because eventually a killed character can be regenerated and does that negate the win?
This simple idea, I fear, would lend less credibility to your argument and you may find that as you address each scenario you may come with multiple valid deductions as in.. pound for pound, out smarted, draw, run away and how does each count? We established fights that end in escapes, reverting to Banner or draws become invalid to the point.
So..
Hulk v Galactis: Galactis would simply consume him, Lose
v Silver Surfer would blast him with the power cosmic, Lose
v Spidy would out maneuver but eventually run ( draw [invalid]) or tire again invalid
v Superman short term Supes may win or draw, long term Supes tires Hulk wins
Dr. Strange magic could provide many outcomes, so a mixed response, that I won't get into...but banished to another dimension? probably a draw by our logic. so invalid
v Wolverine. draw due to his rapid healing (Wolv was torn in half by Hulk so that was a "win" but he revived and healed so was it a win? And it's been shown Adamantium can cut Hulk, given speed and time Wolverine may in time mortally wound Hulk, possible decapitation so lose
v Ghost Rider again magic, does it count? His penance stare would possibly incapacitate Hulk, most likely to a reversion so invalid.
v Phoenix/ dark Phoenix... Suffocation via telepathy? revert invalid Stop his heart? lose
Sue Storm: suffocation via force field to death? again probably revert invalid
v Magnito assuming aside from gamma enhancement Hulk maintains iron in his blood or any metallic manipulation (his control is at the atomic level) so small amounts of metals could be inserted to cause death Lose
Kitty Pride (Shadow Kat) Phase Hulk inside a solid? death... lose

I could go on... it is up to you how you wish to proceed but these make interesting points worth exploring.

Define your criteria for a win, or a what type of face off you are exploring

Gods am I this much of a geek to give it this much consideration?

No comments:

Post a Comment